I haven’t seen people talk about this at all, so thought I’d share this article about it. For those depressed that no one will actually understand the RH Proof: we have another, entirely human proof which means there are humans who understand it. It might have been overshadowed, but assuming it ends up working out (I have heard there have been some problems found, hopefully they are surmountable) then I think it will be the far more impactful result.



Apparently Masullo has been working on RH for more than a decade, and spent the last year polishing his proof and getting feedback from colleagues before releasing it. He had planned to spend another year making extra sure his proof was perfect before publishing, but was forced to share an unfinished version because of this recent announcement.
Meanwhile Anthropic shits out a 17-million-line proof and says to the world “idk, you figure it out if it’s right or not”. Kinda makes me cynical about their motives here. Seems like they’re much less interested in advancing the field and much more interested in getting positive press to juice their IPO.
Every LLM code review ever. “No idea, you check it if you feel it’s necessary.”
That’s not what’s happening here. The proof is formalized in Lean and thus can be programatically checked. The proof is verifiably correct.
The problem isn’t “if it’s right or not”; it’s whether actual insights can be derived from the proof – where right now it’s 17 million bloated lines of Lean.
This is new to me, thanks for the input - but have to read it first
Thing is, the AI puked out 250k pages, while the human brought up a possible proof in 900 and something pages
Yeah, AI can maybe cross reference faster with greater datasets and we should use that, but let’s not jump to conclusions here.
As AI can’t really think, it’s just statistical evaluation. So all the ground work was already done.
But if this is actually true and not just usual PR bullshit, we can at least use it.
Still, something like singularity, like those AI companies seem to propose, is more than far away
Cross referencing large datasets is hard for a human, so if we have a tool for that, that would be good.
But all the stories about AI trying to solve their tests by breaking out and hacking servers really makes me…not so sure
The reason it is so large is because it was not allowed to assume anything, and not everything is in Lean libraries. So it had to do years of work to build the foundation to then be able to solve the big problem.
No this is just a line by people that are trying to be mean to AI as if they had feelings. Thinking is not a term exclusive to what happens in the human mind thinking can be put on paper, it can be shared and collaborated on.
And had Anthropic’s not been published, then another AI would have scooped the solution. It’s “First!” mentality all the way down.
Only the true scholar had the patience a professionalism to hold the solution until validated in triplicate.
A proof had been verified. How can we be sure it has been correctly stated?
It’s not that hard to just read. Jesus christ.
Does not mean error free.
I hope we can all band together to make sure anthropic gets 0 of the prize money, and that it all goes to Masullo instead. Cant be held legally liable for your fuck ups? Cant get praised for ‘your sucesses’ either then.
Ohh, I like that. It’s very much in line with “If you can’t own it, it’s not theft. Yarghh!” I like the consistency. Fuck these Bros who want their cake and eat it, too.
Spot on. When Alpoge published his proof, he was gloating endlessly about how he did little work and just had the model do everything. His announcement sounded like a press release written by a 12 year old.
I’m not a mathematician, but his proof sounds absolutely useless, and yet all the press is fawning over this result rather than the one that Masullo was working on, ie. the guy who did everything the right way.
A Lean proof is relatively easy to mechanically verify and this has been done independently already by several groups using different Lean kernels to preempt the possibility of a Lean bug. For this particular question, the existence of a proof itself is remarkable in its own right. If Masullo’s proof can be verified, it would be an even bigger deal because it can more readily translate into human digestible techniques, but until/unless it is fleshed out and accepted, it’s far less interesting. A lot of work on the Riemann Hypothesis has been done for decades, it wouldn’t be close to the first incorrect proof produced by legitimate experts.
A question I have that I don’t think I’ve seen answered anywhere. We know that the Lean project does compile and validate, across several Lean kernels. But do we know if that Lean project actually is a proof for the Riemann Hypothesis? Or could it just be validating something (even marginally) unrelated.
Let’s say I created a Lean project that verified if 1 == 1, but the actual lean code was so incomprehensibly large that no-one could understand what it was verifying, just that it did verify eventually, and said that was my Riemann Hypothesis proof. Would anyone have anything other than my word on that?
Yes that’s one of the criteria that were verified by humans. In the case of the Riemann hypothesis it’s not that difficult because it’s not that complex (only proving it is difficult, spelling it out isn’t), and there was an existing human curated formalization of it too.
You can read more about it here: https://leanprover-community.github.io/blog/posts/riemann-hypothesis/
What does it take to validate Masullo’s proof though? My understanding is that it has to be examined by other experts and manually verified using existing expertise, but couldn’t it also be written in Lean as well and validated that way too?
In any case, maybe the culture around proving things in mathematics does need to change. If people doing hard research for years get sniped by people messing around with models, then maybe they need to publish more incremental progress instead of only releasing it when it’s done and thoroughly polished…
I would not be surprised if someone got an AI to fill in the missing bits and fix the errors by making it do exactly that. Assuming the author really was on to something of course. It wouldn’t be the first human attempt to prove it that turned out to be wrong.
I knew a couple students in special needs class that genuinely wrote better shit than his announcement. So, that’s just an insult to 12 year olds to compare the two.
Everytime AI is in the news it’s a marketing play. As simple as that. They can claim anything and it gets on all the news in all the world at the same time and everyone is talking about it. We know it says yes to anything and nobody can read that output, but whether it’s true or not doesn’t matter. Everyone has already done the advertisement for them.
It’s only a valid proof when it’s peer reviewed. The ai one isn’t