I did some analysis of the modlog and found this:

Ok, bigger instances ban more often. Not surprising, because they have more communities and more users and more trouble. But hang on, dbzer0 isn’t a very big instance. What happens if we do a ratio of bans vs number of users?

Ok, so lemmy.ml, dbzer0 and pawb are issue an outsized amount of bans for the number of users they have… But surely the number of communities the instance hosts is going to mean they have to ban more? Bans are used to moderate communities, not just to shield their user-base from the outside. Let’s look at the number of bans per community hosted:

Seems like dbzer0 really loves to ban. Even more than the marxists and the furries! What is it about dbzer0 that makes them such prolific banners?
Raw-ish numbers and calculations are in this spreadsheet if anyone wants to make their own charts.
“Hey everyone, look at my juvenile attempts at statistics! Look how obviously bad some people seem when I do a shit job at it while ALSO failing to apply any context of the domain being studied to my thoughts, let alone ‘calculations’ and conclusions!”
This is a terrible metric from the fucking jump. And you did a shit job of it from there. Fuck you, truly.
[Edit: love how ya closed with “so who’s weirder guyz, the marxists, the furries, or the db0s?!” Just painfully obvious how you started the whole shebang, you hate all of the groups lol]
This is a pretty disappointing post Rimu. It appears very out of character from your usual content and feels like a bit of a hit piece.
Also why post it to !fediverse@lemmy.world when you have !fediverse@piefed.social?
What is the modlog for, if not holding moderators to account?
What’s to ‘account’ for banning people?
Do moderators reflect instances or communities?
If communities have high rates of bad-faith posters engaging to troll and harass them, is that something that needs to be held to ‘account’?
Well, I think you make good points. But I also think this information that has been posted is valuable.
Instances and communities are inevitably reflective of the moderators who curate them. Depending on the moderation decisions, the communities and instances naturally evolve as some stuff gets removed/banned, and other stuff gets encouraged.
If communities have high rates of trolls, then naturally they would have higher rates of banning. But the discrepancy visualized here is of a much greater scale than could be explained by mere variations in user/troll activity, imo. It’s fairly obvious that different servers have different standards for moderation, and I think that’s a good thing.
I think the issue being danced around in this thread is the latent assumption that servers with a high amounts of bans are somehow undesirable or problematic. I don’t necessarily agree with that assumption. Although I obviously prefer an extremely minimal censorship paradigm for me personally, I actually don’t think that such an environment is beneficial or desirable for most users. Despite the fact that everyone likes to imagine themselves as open minded and intellectually independent, in reality most people simply aren’t. We seek communities that reinforce our preconceptions and try to protect ourselves from dissenting and hostile voices, because it’s emotionally draining to live in a state of constant conflict and argument.
So idk, I think there is a bit of frustration and competition between different servers at times and that is coming through in this post. But in the greater perspective, the fediverse as a whole benefits from a diversity of moderation styles, so it should be a point of pride for us as fediverse users rather than a point of argument between us as denizens of our individual servers.
Well said.
Why is this out of character? It’s entirely like Rimu to stir up drama against leftist instances.
Reminder that Rimu hates leftists and anti-fascists more than racists and fascists.
Yep.
Rimu has always been interested in creating a fediverse with good moderation. One side of that is piefed’s great moderation tools, another side is posts like this looking at the data on the moderation that’s being done. This is a very typical Rimu post through that lens.
Rimu has always been an opinionated person who injects his own feelings into the code to ban things he doesn’t like.
I wonder how many ‘bans’ Rimu would have under his belt if we added the effects of multiple PieFed instances blacklisting communities for the word ‘meme’ and other hard-coded pettiness.
Dbzero do not tolerate zionism and zionism apologia
They’d also have a very contentious discussion community.
!yepowertrippinbastards@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Edit: fixed link.
Are you surprised the same people who get the most upset about being moderated also abuse moderation the most?
Is that not you? Banning people for Israel?
I explained this the last time you randomly called me a Zionist…
Went and looked at buddies comment history, they are messed in the head lmfao
It is not random, this is truth. You can lie all you want, and many of the people on here will believe you, but we know. You are a Zionist, on Lemmy, as if this was Reddit Banning people for Israel. Fuck that.
You’re messed in the head m8, find some help
You allow the most disgusting lies in your community then ban people who reporting them too fast
Whatcha mean Isreal targets civilians?!?! Can’t kill civvies when ya claim they are all enemy combatants!! Right???
- BB probably
Wow this is really interesting.
Actually this might be a great time to ask you for a feature request: lately I’ve been banned from SO MANY AI communities located on dbzer0, the trouble with that being that I’ve literally never heard of any of these, much less interacted with any of them, presumably even with a downvote.
Is this “harassment” then, to be preemptively banned from something on some other server that I had no intention of ever going to? What if someone were to create 10 communities a day and ban someone from them all? I guess that one would get noticed and shut down, but I would not put it past an AI content generator to do just this sort of thing, if it were given the ability to do so.
Anyway, perhaps those notifications could be silenced unless I’ve ever commented or at least voted in the community that I am being banned from? I don’t need to know or care about something that I have zero interest in - these unsolicited bans are spam.
You were targeted by draconic_neo and mystic mushroom.
They have created a bunch of different communities across the fediverse so they can spam people’s modlogs with bullshit harassment.
See my mod history, it’s exactly the same pattern.
A huge amount of bans all within a few seconds of each other, all from communities modded by draconic_neo or mystic mushroom, if you examine the individual communities you find that they have no activity.
They only exist to spam people’s mod log with nonsense because they can’t press the downvote button hard enough.
I am also sure DraconicNEO has at least an alt that has been active in the days ghe main account showed no activity and when the main is active the alt is inactive and it is for multiple day long periods.
Also the rhetoric and going overboard with personal attacks is the same too.
But yeah, they can be very petty. They banned me from their dead communities once, then when beefing with me, they unbanned me from their communities only to ban me immediately again. Like what was the point?
Like what was the point?
They were bumping the bans to the top of your mod history so their nonsense is the first thing anyone reads.
If a normal person were to call me a troll many times in a row, I would strongly consider blocking them. But I wonder if blocking these people would have any effect upon this spam?
I also find it the height of irony that we are all told by dbzer0 admins that we should strive hard to understand, since those mods must surely have their reasons for doing what they did, whereas if e.g. Lemmy.World were to block calls for outright murder of themselves personally, then all of a sudden moderation should no longer be allowed to moderate that violent rhetoric spammed at them. One rule for thee while another, different rule for me…
Also, I am somewhat anti-AI, but not to the extent of trolling anyone. Though do facts matter anymore - i.e. have these two mods been kicked off of dbzer0 for their false accusations, sent preemptively out to half the Threadiverse?
I also find it the height of irony that we are all told by dbzer0 admins that we should strive hard to understand, since those mods must surely have their reasons for doing what they did
That would be a fair argument except for the fact that the ‘communities’ that they ‘moderate’ have zero actual activity. Some have posts by draconic, some have exactly zero posts (and the community is locked). They’re just squatting communities with popular Reddit counterparts.
Though do facts matter anymore - i.e. have these two mods been kicked off of dbzer0 for their false accusations, sent preemptively out to half the Threadiverse?
Their dbzer0 account is still active, with comments 3 days ago.
That’s a good idea!
Then I am glad I mentioned it!:-)
Did you go by total bans or only instance bans when they are admins?
Because if it was total bans, then I can think of admins of two other sites who’d be over 300
@rimu@piefed.social
I’m not even a real instance anymore, how did I make the list 😆
But also, you should see the local numbers haha
lemmy=# select count(distinct other_person_id) from mod_ban where mod_person_id in (1, 2,288); count ------- 9792 (1 row)I wonder what happens when I hit 10,000?
You are there because when you ban someone on an instance level, you also ban them on a community level, which inflates your numbers.
DB0 does the same thing.
I used to do that but once the backend added that feature I removed that step from the automod script. Basically it was to prevent the communities here from being unmoddable on remote instances.
That’s just how lemmy works when you ban with content deletion. It needs to work that way so that the content removal for content posted to local communities federates correctly
Unsurprisingly .ml is a shithole everyone thinks it is.
The overwhelming majority of bans on Lemmy.ml are temporary, and the permas are for repeat abusers, or bigots.

Ar nar, you’ve summoned the butthurt tankies!
Roll for initiative.
Analysis of potential causes aside, thank you for sharing such interesting data!
Ah, time for some drama entertainment. I already grabbed the popcorn and some drinks.
What happens if we do a ratio of bans vs number of users?
We get a graph that compares two unrelated values?
Unless this data is purely internal instance user bannings, ‘Per capita’ has no effective meaning. As the pawb.social case shows: it’s all one user with multiple communities who regularly bans waves of sockpuppet brigades. Even the people catching strays or otherwise goes to show it has nothing to do with ‘the furries’.
Likewise I wager the SJW bans are effectively one community banning essentially one user who periodically spams accounts.
What is it about dbzer0 that makes them such prolific banners?
That whole painfully public fued against db0 over their stance on zionism may have something to do with it. Like the fake neo-nazi shit being spread against db0 that was just going on this week. It’s a wild question to have in light of all that, quite frankly.
Interesting that you chose ban when your favorite move is to just delete users you don’t like from the database on piefed.social and won’t show up in this dataset. Of course, you won’t see this reply because of that.
Ah shit, I don’t know what to make of this, but it’s juicy
I don’t know why but the way this post was written made me read it in Tim Pool’s voice. Guess I gotta lay off majority report videos for a while now. Glad to see push back and acknowledgement in the comments that this data is irrelevant. It’s neat, but way too many factors and stretching of meanings which makes this a worthless analysis (with a very blatant bias in the reporting).
Db0 users calling lemmy.world and feddit.org “ban happy” are gonna have an aneurysm.
So very anarchist of them policing their instances heavier than literally any other.
Alternative view: Why is dbzer0 the only instance that holds people accountable for their actions? Why are all other instances letting things slide?
















