• 0 Posts
  • 59 Comments
Joined 4 months ago
cake
Cake day: August 9th, 2025

help-circle

  • The Chinese Han culture absolutely set out to colonise, conquer and subjugated other areas. Xinjiang, Tibet, Mongolia and Manchuria were all conquered during the Qing dynasty and Zhang He projected power and subjugated city states and cultures during his many naval expeditions out.

    Colonisation was common all across all cultures. Look at how the Aztec acted towards their many neighbours.

    The reason European colonisation was so “successful” was just a “lucky” fluke of circumstances and technological evolution. Had the same conditions occurred in China first, Europeans would all have been subjugated by them. Not because the many Chinese cultures are worse or better than ours but simply because it’s been an incredibly commonplace activity across all cultures. The European colonisation was just the most “successful”.




  • Yes, I agree.

    But I think you need to see it in the larger context. Episode 1, and much of season 1 (series 1 as we would call it here in the UK), is about moving into their world so we get to known them and appreciate them. Jen is the viewers’ guide into this world and her journey towards becoming one of them is the viewer’s journey. So what starts as a laugh at geeks ends up sympathising with the geeks (“but we did all the work!!”) and becoming the geeks (observe how Jen’s office starts as a managers office but slowly ends up with Manga artwork).

    So her laughing at the geeks, and her inability to understand them (white noise), is crucial because it takes the viewer’s hand and leads them into the basement.


  • Well let’s start with the jokes. They are just subjectively funnier, with many tie-backs and connections (Seinfeld/CYE long running set ups).

    TITC is laughing at the normies and celebrating the geeks. TITC isn’t afraid to be really funny, which means recognising the human condition and laughing with it. The characters aren’t “good people who fail”, they are “humans who fail”, which mean we recognise them and empathise with them. Who hasn’t wanted to give a really impressive speech and said some bullshit.

    BBT is bland. The characters are bland, with only external failures. The jokes dare not really poke fun at anyone and the jokes are sentence-long. Finally the actors and the script just aren’t as out there, so it all just feels dull as dishwater.