Ok, so robots with jobs. That’s not hands-off automation that allows “luxury”, but we’ll roll with it.
Automation shrinks menial labor, it doesn’t eliminate it. Someone still maintains the machines, does medicine, plans infrastructure, and handles emergencies. Furthermore, robots don’t make more land, water, or energy. We live in a scarcity society because things are scarce. “Post scarcity” luxury, like I imagine you are pulling from Aaron Bastani, isn’t possible where we are, because to give everyone “luxury” we either need more of what’s scarce, or we as a people need to want less. If we had either one of those now, then we wouldn’t be in the pickle we are. These luxuries also have to be distributed by someone , and that’s where every utopia runs into a problem. Who watches the watchmen? Lastly, “work is optional” only works if enough people choose to do the hard stuff, and without a mechanism to guarantee that we end up with the haves and have-nots again, but with 100% more robots.
Nobody’s claiming FALC is achievable with the technology we have today, it’s an ideal rather than an ongoing attempt. Yes, there’s challenges and people are the hardest part of it, see my comment above about people ruining utopia. It’s not to say it’s impossible either, just that we haven’t figured it out.
That works for me, and we seem to agree for the most part. Using tech to cut out the bullshit and spread abundance is a good goal to have. My issue with it is treating the destination as a system that can be built, when the unsolved angle is people, not infrastructure. Until someone figures out how to keep the watchmen in check, then it’s not a plan, it’s a direction. So, in reply to the original question: As a direction, sure. As a system? Not until we figure out how to make people happy.
The fully automated doesn’t refer to oversight, it refers to using automation to eliminate the need for menial labor, making all work optional.
Ok, so robots with jobs. That’s not hands-off automation that allows “luxury”, but we’ll roll with it.
Automation shrinks menial labor, it doesn’t eliminate it. Someone still maintains the machines, does medicine, plans infrastructure, and handles emergencies. Furthermore, robots don’t make more land, water, or energy. We live in a scarcity society because things are scarce. “Post scarcity” luxury, like I imagine you are pulling from Aaron Bastani, isn’t possible where we are, because to give everyone “luxury” we either need more of what’s scarce, or we as a people need to want less. If we had either one of those now, then we wouldn’t be in the pickle we are. These luxuries also have to be distributed by someone , and that’s where every utopia runs into a problem. Who watches the watchmen? Lastly, “work is optional” only works if enough people choose to do the hard stuff, and without a mechanism to guarantee that we end up with the haves and have-nots again, but with 100% more robots.
Nobody’s claiming FALC is achievable with the technology we have today, it’s an ideal rather than an ongoing attempt. Yes, there’s challenges and people are the hardest part of it, see my comment above about people ruining utopia. It’s not to say it’s impossible either, just that we haven’t figured it out.
That works for me, and we seem to agree for the most part. Using tech to cut out the bullshit and spread abundance is a good goal to have. My issue with it is treating the destination as a system that can be built, when the unsolved angle is people, not infrastructure. Until someone figures out how to keep the watchmen in check, then it’s not a plan, it’s a direction. So, in reply to the original question: As a direction, sure. As a system? Not until we figure out how to make people happy.
Oh yeah, anybody claiming to have the plans for FALC right now is selling a bridge.