Hardship itself is not the point; its the means to fulfillment. It’s rooted in DNA. Okay… I made that up, but the point is- it’s a means to an end that is fundamental to our very nature.
Think, “I’ve done it, clawed myself out of the mud, been the first of our kind to see the sunrise, furthered the species! Wow, I feel amazing!” It’s an interesting philosophical question though, “What do we do when we’ve done everything needed secure our future?” I’m not sure inventing a problem in a “fully automated” utopia would work to achieve that. I mean, that’s essentially video games, soduku, etc. problems with no purpose or meaning. There is no fulfillment.
Would we pivot to purely exploration and discovery? Maybe some of us could, but not as a species. We can’t even agree to stop pumping carbon into the atmosphere.
It would be interesting research at least. Plus… for ADHDers like me, we just wouldn’t do the made up problems. We know they aren’t really problems and we would do the things that are fun, rather than the things that “need” doing.
It doesn’t have to be made up challenges! Find something to do that makes things better for others and isn’t easy to accomplish. Just because our basic needs are met doesn’t mean we won’t have any more wants. They’ll just change from physical luxuries to things that are more service-gated.
I understand that utopia by definition means no where and that it’s supposed to be a satirical jab at the notion of perfect and how by nature we will always be dissatisfied with something, but I also understand that the definition has shifted to be unironic.
A philosophical utopia is impossible, but a practical utopia could be managed by an Excel sheet and a calculator. The only reason we don’t have one already is because the suffering was always the point.
Only if it has gay space habitats
Seriously speaking though, only idiots don’t want utopia.
Define utopia. I personally believe the key to true happiness requires a bit of hardship, or there can be no fulfillment.
There’s nothing preventing artificial hardship, set a goal for yourself and achieve it.
Hardship itself is not the point; its the means to fulfillment. It’s rooted in DNA. Okay… I made that up, but the point is- it’s a means to an end that is fundamental to our very nature.
Think, “I’ve done it, clawed myself out of the mud, been the first of our kind to see the sunrise, furthered the species! Wow, I feel amazing!” It’s an interesting philosophical question though, “What do we do when we’ve done everything needed secure our future?” I’m not sure inventing a problem in a “fully automated” utopia would work to achieve that. I mean, that’s essentially video games, soduku, etc. problems with no purpose or meaning. There is no fulfillment.
Would we pivot to purely exploration and discovery? Maybe some of us could, but not as a species. We can’t even agree to stop pumping carbon into the atmosphere.
It would be interesting research at least. Plus… for ADHDers like me, we just wouldn’t do the made up problems. We know they aren’t really problems and we would do the things that are fun, rather than the things that “need” doing.
It doesn’t have to be made up challenges! Find something to do that makes things better for others and isn’t easy to accomplish. Just because our basic needs are met doesn’t mean we won’t have any more wants. They’ll just change from physical luxuries to things that are more service-gated.
commies live for the struggle, it’s dramatic, heroic, sexy and any old idiot can get into it. kinda like jesus, mohammed and super heroes
Huh, i understood that only idiots do want utopia, considering it is pretty much impossible to achieve
Humans ruin utopia. But I guess it depends on what your definition of utopia is. FALC comes close enough for me.
I understand that utopia by definition means no where and that it’s supposed to be a satirical jab at the notion of perfect and how by nature we will always be dissatisfied with something, but I also understand that the definition has shifted to be unironic.
A philosophical utopia is impossible, but a practical utopia could be managed by an Excel sheet and a calculator. The only reason we don’t have one already is because the suffering was always the point.