My first several dates with a guy I met on a dating app were great, and we recently became exclusive after a month and a half, but now more issues and patterns are popping up - including previous infidelity incidents - and I’m really sad and feel trapped, unsure how to proceed with him from here. I would really appreciate any advice and help because I had so much hope for us and feel attached but also extremely conflicted.
We agree how naturally we click and how effortlessly conversation flows. I’ve felt a magnetic pull, strong attraction, and excitement about our potential. I like many of his qualities, he’s respectful and chivalrous (didn’t try anything physical on 1st date), listened to my preferences communicated for kissing and boundaries in having sex after things become more established/official (although he’s repeatedly said “he wants to be inside me even just a little bit” - to be fair, I’ve been initiating other forms of physical intimacy so we’ve been in frisky situations and his comments don’t feel like pressure. He has also been very patient with my schedule (overdue intermittent travel after stressful career-intensive years), physical intimacy preferences, and an important project I’m busy with so need more time before he comes over to my place.
Now, the issues… He recently admitted to me that he had a year-long affair, which ended just earlier this year, with an engaged woman who allegedly had discussed with her fiance that she could have a “hall pass” aka one more friend with benefits before tying the knot. However, there was grey area and a period of time when they continued sneaking around without her husband being aware. My date was describing it as if he was the victim and how she messed with him mentally, leading to severe trust issues for him. I asked if he was ever threatened by her or cheated on a partner he had, and he said no. Well, she’s married now and done with her fling with him. But she is more senior to him at the same company, and they work together daily now. He claims he has no interest in her, and feels truly remorseful and disgusted by the entire situation.
Even so, hearing this made my heart sink. I was genuinely wanting this to work out. I myself have struggled with trust and security issues, which I am actively working through, and I will be the first to say I am not perfect. In our vulnerable moment, I shared that I also had a moment of weakness 10 years ago when we were all more young and naive. My ex was repeatedly pursuing me during a failing relationship I had with someone else, and we kissed once. I felt so guilty I told my boyfriend right away and we tried for another couple of months.
Right before the infidelity discussion, my date shut down after I respectfully and gently suggested how to pleasure me better, and he retaliated wanting to stop abruptly saying he already wasn’t feeling invested in the moment before I even said anything. I felt this was defensive and passive-aggressive when I was simply trying to encourage candid communication and was excited to satisfy him. I cried when he said maybe I should bring myself back home so we can “reassess”, even though we both longed for this night all week. We talked it out and I ultimately stayed overnight but was so drained after, it slipped my mind to add that I previously kissed two other guys who were in long-distance relationships, one 10 years ago and one earlier this year (nothing more than a kiss). He did say he feels like he can trust me more after I opened up about my ex incident, and we actually had a surprisingly enjoyable and passionate time together extending into today.
I’m feeling quite raw so would appreciate if you could all be gentle with me. What do you all recommend that I do for next steps? Is it worth giving another chance if someone who has cheated or enabled cheating expresses regret and guilt about their mistake? Should I give this more time and accept more dates (assuming he’s still willing), or distance myself citing busy schedule without explicitly closing the door? I just find it difficult to completely burn the bridge right now and don’t want to lose him in case it can resolve.


I mean this in the best way possible, but you both sound a little naive here(in a healthy way really) about how relationships work.
It sounds like you like him, he likes you. You both were lied to by previous partners, and you both have trust issues.
There’s no shortcut here outside of talking everything through.
I encourage you to talk to him about this, not that you can’t also talk to internet strangers about it, but the person you need to work through your issues with is the guy you’re dating.
If you expect everyone’s dating past to be clean, then you’re in for a world of disappointment when you get manipulated by someone with a "squeaky clean"dating history.
If anything, having some bad experiences and making some bad decisions can be healthy, as long as the person learns from them and tries to be better and shows real change in their life.
The key is always open communication. Always. No lying, and talking about your issues openly with each other, even when it’s not comfortable.
If he lied to you, or misled you, that’s a flag and you need to determine if that’s something worth risking in the relationship or working to “fix”.
But if not? Well, people fuck up and make poor choices all the time because we’re horny monkeys. What matters is if they recognize their mistakes, why it happened, and incorporate those lessons into making themselves a better person.
It sounds like he trusted you enough to open up about a part of his dating history he was ashamed of, and that’s a big step in the right direction. He’s going to be incredibly sensitive to your reactions here, and will likely be overly defensive if you’re not able to accept that part of his past (and that’s a call you alone need to make).
Regarding the how to better please you part, I might advise that in the future, that be a separate conversation completely, and not shoehorned into another one about past dating and partner mistakes.
It’s an important and healthy conversation to have, but you guys haven’t figured out how to trust each other’s previous relationships yet, so a more intimate conversation is likely too much to handle right now.
Build on your communication, strengthen your trust with each other and get to the point where you feel like you could literally tell each other anything and everything and there would be no judgement, and then things like how to better please each other will be one of the most exciting and normal things to bring up.
Basically, you’re putting the cart before the horse a bit on that. I get it, I understand it, but it sounds like you’ve got work to do before that conversation isn’t awkward or combative.