• astanix@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    11
    ·
    21 hours ago

    The weird thing is once all the workers are gone that means they have no job which means no income which means no money spend… what happens then?

    • TheRagingGeek@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      8
      ·
      20 hours ago

      That’s the part that always confuses me as capitalists what is the end game when you eliminate workers? Cause you also ultimately eliminate consumers and ultimately profits

      • boonhet@sopuli.xyz
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        4
        ·
        edit-2
        18 hours ago

        The workers are already dying off, we’re not reproducing at a high enough rate and never will again (only developing countries have high birth rates, partly because they need to have kids to take care of them in old age). Only around 2 workers for 1 pensioner in some western countries nowadays! Used to be double digits.

        This is a problem for the retirement class who owns everything even more than it is for the billionaire class that has more power, but actually owns less because they’re less numerous - turns out you need a LOT of resources to keep untold amounts of old people happy and healthy.

        It also turns out, that there are two main ways retirement systems work: The ones where you invest for your own future (systems like 401ks for Americans) and the ones where you, the worker, pay for old people to retire, and in turn, others will pay for you to retire later. The former causes a ton of inequality: In the US, people over 55 own 73% of all wealth, baby boomers alone own over 50% - and even among old people there is still a lot of inequality, only like 20% are millionaires. It thus means that for old people to have the best possible retirement, young people need to be paid as little as possible. For the second type of system, this is not an issue, but the issue is that to keep the pension growing with inflation, the ratio of workers to retirees shouldn’t fall. If it does, taxes need to go up. There are some who will say “just print more money”, but apparently you can’t eat money, nor live in it. Things need to be made that you can buy for this money. Even communism can’t save you from there being no workers to produce anything, if there are people who need those things but are too old to work.

        So either way, for old people to get to enjoy life without working, there need to be either more workers, or the workers need to be abused more. What if there was a third way? There is! The third way is for productivity per worker to go up. But if you’re demand constrained, more productivity per worker means fewer workers.

        Of course, under capitalism, that’s going to suck for the workers who lose their jobs. But eventually there should be degrowth that happens naturally.

        If, on the other hand, you lived in a system where everyone gets access to exactly the same resources whether they have a job or not, that is no longer a problem and the reduction in jobs should be seen as a positive.