None of them are a replacement for Steam Controller. I purchased one specifically because of the two trackpads, that I’m used to on my Steam Deck. I can use the same configuration on Steam Deck and Controller. Besides that, there are other technical reasons I’m not getting into. I have Xbox controllers and a modern 8bitdo Ultimate 2 Wireless Controller. I don’t want to play Steam games without a Steam Controller (or Deck) ever again!
None of them are a replacement for Steam Controller. I purchased one specifically because of the two trackpads, that I’m used to on my Steam Deck. I can use the same configuration on Steam Deck and Controller. Besides that, there are other technical reasons I’m not getting into. I have Xbox controllers and a modern 8bitdo Ultimate 2 Wireless Controller. I don’t want to play Steam games without a Steam Controller (or Deck) ever again!